The 2013 Red Sox: Worse Than 2012?

by Denton on November 24, 2012

The Hot Stove is on, but I don’t like the smell of what’s cooking. It smells like failure. The Red Sox staggered out of the 2012 season a broken team with a lot of gaping holes to fill. So far, what they’ve done to fill those holes has not been impressive.

Manager: John Farrell – I think my view on this move is well documented. Another case of Red Sox obsession. They had a fictitious “search” for a manger but Farrell was their only real target. Not a great track record for Johnny and by the looks of it, he’ll have a very Toronto-like team to work with.

Outfield: Jonny Gomes. Is it really that hard to find a decent outfielder without overpaying? Look at J.D. Drew, Mike Cameron, Carl Crawford – all good players at a reasonable salary, just not worth what the Sox paid. Gomes is more of the same. The Sox are paying him five million each for the next two years. Gomes has never made more than two million in his career, and was on a one year, one million dollar contract last year. Oh, and he is a horrible outfielder and a raging douchebag.

In the hunt: Mike Napoli and Nick Swisher. It seems the idea is for the Sox to go out and get the players that only play well against the Red Sox. Not a very sound strategy. I would pass on both of these guys. Napoli can’t play first with any stability and Swisher at four years, sixty million sounds like another major disappointment in the making.

Remember when the Sox used to get guys like Manny, Schilling and Pedro? Yeah, that was awesome.

6 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
JMalcolm
JMalcolm

While I don't disagree, I also think that this year is going to be one of getting back to the basics that led us to 2004/2007 (primarily 2004). With the promising young guys either in Boston or waiting in the wings until 2014, 2013 could be a year to develop and explore some opportunities without completely giving the season away. That being said, the FA market is pretty bleak and it certainly isn't worth it to overpay for the collection of players out there just to get something done, or just because we have the money in another Crawford situation.

TheOmnipotentQ
TheOmnipotentQ like.author.displayName 1 Like

I'm totally reserving judgment, Denton. Way too early to start giving up on 2013. FA market is very thin, so I'm betting Ben makes a big splash with a big trade. Or two.

VJ in Stuttgart
VJ in Stuttgart

@TheOmnipotentQ I agree. Maybe there's something we don't know? The moves are curious, in a thin market. Judgement is out, so we'll wait for the first PBR induced coma by Red to be the judge.

Mersh_Danger
Mersh_Danger

I agree. I wish I didn't. But I do. Ugh. 

Good post. 

mikecarlucci
mikecarlucci

Health can't be assumed, but a full season of Will Middlebrooks should be an upgrade over 2012 Youk and the Pedro Ciriaco/Mike Aviles-lead cast of misfits.

The money for Gomes? Does seem like a premium based on history. We'll know more about the OF market when Ross, Swisher, and Ichiro are signed. Maybe it will make more sense then.

mattymatty2000
mattymatty2000

Don't necessarily disagree, but it's not like Manny, Schilling, and Pedro are out there waiting to be got. Times are ever so slightly different.

Previous post:

Next post: