Papel-Gone?

by Denton on December 17, 2010

With Daniel Bard already waiting in the wings, could the Red Sox signing of Bobby Jenks signal the end of the Jonathan Papelbon era in Boston?

Papelbon has been very outspoken about “setting the bar” for other closers in terms of salary, making his long-term future in Boston an uncertainty , but this could shorten his stay. 2010 was, by Papelbon standards, a bad year, but his stats were mystifying. His ERA doubled and he blew a career-worst eight saves, but his hits allowed, walks, strikeouts, innings pitched, homeruns allowed and total saves were very similar to his 2009 season. In fact, even the saber-geek stats that I don’t even understand looked eerily like 2009.

What does that tell us? That he just wasn’t getting the big outs when he needed them? That he was just unlucky? I have no idea, but watching him pitch last season was like sitting in the waiting room at the proctologist’s office. You just couldn’t get comfortable.

What is the pulse out there: is the Jenks move strictly to strengthen the bullpen and protection against an injury to Paps or Bard, or is there a trade in the works? The way Theo has been wheeling and dealing, a trade would not be a surprise. Personally, I’d like to see Papelbon stick around for at least one more October dance.

48 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
BB
BB

i was referring to the old time regulars (not the new regulars), circa 2004-2005.

sanfransoxfan
sanfransoxfan

This format is definitely more game thread friendly. I think a general pre-game agreement to ignore the troll(s) and then sticking to it (guilty as charged here for failing - do as I say, not as I do) will cause the attention seeking troll(s) to whither on the vine.

This site is too fun to lose, and this season is going to be '07ish! I'd like to spend more time here.

hayes
hayes

Yeah, you're right - it just felt like a gut-punch and that he was giving up those hits on purpose last year.  It's just more shitty that he was so fucking lights out before...He surly needs more than two pitches.

hayes
hayes

Yeah, you're right - it just felt like a gut-punch and that he was giving up those hits on purpose last year.  It's just more shitty that he was so fucking lights out before...He surly needs more than two pitches.

Nikki
Nikki

No, he's not.

The fact that there are a couple players on the roster who were born in 1990 blows my damn mind.

edward
edward

Strength in numbers ... pap will close this year, bard the next and into the future.
Jenks is set up ... Is Okie still around?

Tex
Tex

I miss everyone here posting during games
I dont mind dealing with trolls here. Too hard to keep up with pots on FB during games

Is it April yet?

mike
mike

I believe it's a simple case of hedging one's bet.  Jenks isn't a huge risk (expensive) and Paps has thrown a round house by his words... I believe you take paps at his word and start the separation process by signing Jenks. 

mike
mike

I believe it's a simple case of hedging one's bet.  Jenks isn't a huge risk (expensive) and Paps has thrown a round house by his words... I believe you take paps at his word and start the separation process by signing Jenks. 

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

I disagree Hayes.  =-X

 His ineffectiveness was because he had a fastball with no movement, and a curve that was a bit predictable. Not really a curve (slider, whatever). He needs to have 3 effective pitches. And the fastball needs to come up to about 94-96, not 91-93. 

Only Rivera can throw the same thing and get away with it. Because it is barely hittable. You have to be patient with him and maybe hit a mistake. Paps, his pitches seemed to be very easy to predict. 

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

I disagree Hayes.  =-X

 His ineffectiveness was because he had a fastball with no movement, and a curve that was a bit predictable. Not really a curve (slider, whatever). He needs to have 3 effective pitches. And the fastball needs to come up to about 94-96, not 91-93. 

Only Rivera can throw the same thing and get away with it. Because it is barely hittable. You have to be patient with him and maybe hit a mistake. Paps, his pitches seemed to be very easy to predict. 

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

There was no defection BB, just an alternate universe that lets us pick and choose. It keeps certain people from lurking there. And they know who they are. 

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

There was no defection BB, just an alternate universe that lets us pick and choose. It keeps certain people from lurking there. And they know who they are. 

BB
BB

oops, that was me channeling the goatman....

Matt Clement
Matt Clement

that was the good old days.....  before all you fuckos defected to facebook. ;)  

Matt Clement
Matt Clement

that was the good old days.....  before all you fuckos defected to facebook. ;)  

Matt Clement
Matt Clement

good for him, I hope he gets to play everyday, he deserves a shot.

hayes
hayes

He'll stay this year and we'll all have ulcers.  His issues seem to be mental, but what do I know...maybe the close competition will improve him.  I'm am sensing the ghost of gagne...

hayes
hayes

He'll stay this year and we'll all have ulcers.  His issues seem to be mental, but what do I know...maybe the close competition will improve him.  I'm am sensing the ghost of gagne...

hayes
hayes

Fabulous...didn't we have used to have haiku wednesdays or something?

jeff
jeff

what's better than 2 good relievers? 3...

Matt Clement
Matt Clement

better - ??

keep paplebon's ass
bard can't set up and close too
jenks? no fucking way

Got2be
Got2be

Keep Paps on, I've seen Jenks close and we don't need that.  He makes Paps look good on his worst day.  Jenks should strictly be a setup man (though a rather expensive one)

Got2be
Got2be

Keep Paps on, I've seen Jenks close and we don't need that.  He makes Paps look good on his worst day.  Jenks should strictly be a setup man (though a rather expensive one)

DeathOpie
DeathOpie

I think he stays for this year and then gone.  Sox are going for it in '11.

DeathOpie
DeathOpie

I think he stays for this year and then gone.  Sox are going for it in '11.

Sleepingisoverrated
Sleepingisoverrated

I just can't picture Paps going anywhere before the July deadline... and even then... if he get his act together and is insanely awesome destroying hitters with a new breaking pitch, do we trade him?

Hell no!!!

Alexis
Alexis

Yes, I did see your response. :)  Sorry for the delay in getting back.

Alexis
Alexis

Yes, I did see your response. :)  Sorry for the delay in getting back.

Rich in the garage
Rich in the garage

If you read the article on the globe Denton, it says "Jenks was told he will be a set up man" or something to that extent and that "he could compete for the closer job WHEN Papelbon leaves." 

Keep him in a contract year, lets see what hes capable of when it matter to him. 

Rich in the garage
Rich in the garage

If you read the article on the globe Denton, it says "Jenks was told he will be a set up man" or something to that extent and that "he could compete for the closer job WHEN Papelbon leaves." 

Keep him in a contract year, lets see what hes capable of when it matter to him. 

Pip
Pip

Papelbon is gone, and that's ok.  Be it this off season, during the season, or next off season.  So this move is the logical step.  I vote for just letting him walk.  He's in a contract year so he'll be on his game. And last year we learned the value of having depth to deal with injuries, so again, I vote to let it ride, we should be in a position to win either way.  Injury? We'll have depth.  Paps sucks, we have Bard.  Paps kicks ass, cool, we have him.

Pip
Pip

Papelbon is gone, and that's ok.  Be it this off season, during the season, or next off season.  So this move is the logical step.  I vote for just letting him walk.  He's in a contract year so he'll be on his game. And last year we learned the value of having depth to deal with injuries, so again, I vote to let it ride, we should be in a position to win either way.  Injury? We'll have depth.  Paps sucks, we have Bard.  Paps kicks ass, cool, we have him.

BB
BB

getting rid of paplebon is stupid.
bard can't set up and close.
jenks as the full time closer?  no fucking way.

BB
BB

getting rid of paplebon is stupid.
bard can't set up and close.
jenks as the full time closer?  no fucking way.

English Sox Fan
English Sox Fan

Mrs ESF and I "traded" Papelbon from our Red Sox McFarlane figures Hall of Fame just last week.  Wonder if the real Sox will follow suit? 

*off into London today for three nights, and the snow has just started to fall*

English Sox Fan
English Sox Fan

Mrs ESF and I "traded" Papelbon from our Red Sox McFarlane figures Hall of Fame just last week.  Wonder if the real Sox will follow suit? 

*off into London today for three nights, and the snow has just started to fall*

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

I think Theo and Co. sit back and watch what happens in spring / early summer. They should have a feel for which way to go. If Paps learns something other than a 91 mph ball that gets creamed, with no movement, then we have a great pen.

Or he's gone by July for a complimentary / missing piece.

One or the other.  

VJ in Okinawa
VJ in Okinawa

I think Theo and Co. sit back and watch what happens in spring / early summer. They should have a feel for which way to go. If Paps learns something other than a 91 mph ball that gets creamed, with no movement, then we have a great pen.

Or he's gone by July for a complimentary / missing piece.

One or the other.  

Ray
Ray

Personally, I feel that he's gonna end up being that "player to be named" on the way to San Diego before long...they gave us a big name, we're giving them one.  They did say the PTBN'ed wasn't a prime prospect...could be likely, but they've got a decent closer out in SD already, so I could be wrong - in fact, I hope I'm wrong.  I'll have to agree with wanting him to stick around for one more October dance.

Ray
Ray

Personally, I feel that he's gonna end up being that "player to be named" on the way to San Diego before long...they gave us a big name, we're giving them one.  They did say the PTBN'ed wasn't a prime prospect...could be likely, but they've got a decent closer out in SD already, so I could be wrong - in fact, I hope I'm wrong.  I'll have to agree with wanting him to stick around for one more October dance.

Nikki
Nikki

Stats aside, I just can't see him fitting in anywhere but here.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Chip Cole, Red. Red said: Papel-Gone? http://bit.ly/h1VJck [...]

Previous post:

Next post: